Search blog.co.uk

As the dust settles...

by Rampage @ Wednesday, Sep. 03, 2008 - 11:43:52

..on the close of the transfer window, something seems very, very wrong.

Why were only English clubs going utterly, utterly bananas?

If we have a look at the major signings in the other leagues, it really makes shocking reading.

In Spain, probably the biggest transfer was Rafael Van Der Vaart from Hamburg to Real. He cost just over 12 million pounds. Equate that to the English market: James Milner went to Villa from Newcastle for the same amount. Apart from van der Vaart, Spain's biggest signing was probably managing to keep David Villa there - he signed a new contract with Valencia despite attention from Chelsea and Man City.

Germany's biggest action was mostly in Wolfsburg, recently bloated by large investment. They picked up the Italian duo of Christian Zaccardo and Andrea Barzagli for undisclosed fees, but also invested heavily in youth from lower leagues. Tim Borowski's move from Bremen to Bayern was a free transfer, as was Lehmann's to Stuttgart, while Bremen picked up Claudio Pizarro on a year-long loan.

French teams never usually create transfer shockwaves, and this summer was no different. Still, some interesting transfers took place: Hatem Ben Arfa from Lyon to Marseille (9.5m, much cheaper than the world-beater James Milner), Monaco picked up Freddy Adu on loan, and Nantes look to have done an astute piece of business with the signing of Ivan Klasnic from Bremen.

Italian clubs, as usual, dealed heavily amongst themselves. Fiorentina could have acquired James Milner for 12 million pounds, but instead they went for Alberto Gilardino for the same amount. Time will tell if they made the right call. Granted, Inter threw some cash around, for Quaresma (25m) and Muntari (12m) but their behaviour was the exception to the rule on the peninsula this summer.

Let's have a look at English teams' spending:
Robinho Man City-Real Madrid 32.5
Berbatov Man Utd-Spurs 30.7
Keane Liverpool-Spurs 20.3
Jo Man City-CSKA Moscow 18
Bosingwa Chelsea-Porto 16.2
Modric Spurs-Dinamo Zagreb 15.8
Fellaini Everton-Standard Liège 15
Bentley Spurs-Blackburn 15
Pavlyuchenko Spurs-Spartak Moscow 14
Milner Villa-Newcastle 12

So why is it? Why do English teams have so much more money than their European counterparts? Only recently have English teams come to dominate European football - for years they languished behind the likes of Bayern, Milan, Real and Barcelona. The Champions League provides huge rewards, but it's not as if Spurs or Everton have seen any of it.

And what is it about English clubs that attracts foreign investment? What do they have that other European sides don't? Is is simply a willingness to sell their souls for a quick buck? I know for sure that I would HATE for my beloved Sampdoria to be bought out - there is so much more to my love for them than desire to see them succeed.

And, most importantly, is the romanticiasm gone out of English football? Kaiserslautern won the German league the year after promotion in 1998. Chievo lead Serie A for six weeks in their first year there in 2002, eventually qualifiying for the UEFA Cup. Can English football over the last ten years offer anything like this?

Yikes, this post has gone on for much longer than intended. Still, would very much like to hear what you fellow footy fans think.


 
 

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

JuzzzyJuzzzy [Member]
http://juzzzy.blog.co.uk
03/09/08 @ 14:40

Simple - Sky.

The moment the Premier League was created, football went mad.

And because people are prepared to pay for it, the footage goes to the highest bidder which of course has been, and will no doubt continue to be, Murdoch.

The Champions League is worthless to Everton or Spurs because they can't get into it. Being in it earns the clubs millions, meaning they can buy the players to keep them in it, and thus you have the vicious circle.

Interesting stuff in The Times today (and presumably the others) about how the Man City takeover puts a new dimension on the Premiership, though: Now there are two stupendously wealthy men whose pockets are so deep, they'll probably end dispensing with the football itself and just trying shooting each other on the pitch.

It's almost time to consider watching the Championship.

RampageRampage team
03/09/08 @ 17:23

Ah, Sky, had forgotten about that little earner. Still though, European teams pull in lots of money from their own TV contracts.

Two rich twats shooting each other across a football pitch? Now that's a game I wouldn't mind paying 50 quid for.

JuzzzyJuzzzy [Member]
http://juzzzy.blog.co.uk
03/09/08 @ 18:01

Nothing like the Premiership, though. You only have to travel to places like the Far East to see how nuts they are about it over there. Every other person is wearing a Premiership shirt.

All of those countries and their various networks pay for access to the shows.... up goes the money into clubs... and so up go the stakes for staying either in the Premiership itself or even better, the Champions League... and so up goes the desperation to have the best players, thus paying whatever they can afford... and up go the ticket prices.

RampageRampage team
04/09/08 @ 11:58

The ticket prices are another big difference. For Hertha BSC, a season ticket costs €150. For a mid-table premiership team, say, Middlesborough, prices start at 429 quid. Can't understand how British fans are able and willing to invest so juch cash in their teams.

deleted user [Visitor]

05/09/08 @ 21:32

With the Man City takeover, I would say that the Premier League is now a "Big 3" in terms of spending power. United can spend as big as Chelsea and City, its just whether or not the Utd board would be willing to keep spending to try and keep pace with the real big spenders in the Prem!

RampageRampage team
09/09/08 @ 11:35

United don't really need to though, they have an outstanding manager, stable infrastructure, owners that don't interfere and a team that can already do the business.

deleted user [Visitor]

09/09/08 @ 12:31

As your little list up there says, they did go out and spend more than £30 million on Berbatov so presumably they do feel that they need to carry on spending!

RampageRampage team
09/09/08 @ 12:34

You're right, but he was someone they had identified as their target over a year ago and they got the man they wanted, rather than just flinging money at any random player, like City appear to be doing now. :)

deleted user [Visitor]

09/09/08 @ 12:36

Flinging money around looks like so much fun though, after all we did it ourselves with that Fellaini! :)

RampageRampage team
09/09/08 @ 12:40

True, that signing really confused me. He didn't look up to much when I saw him v Liverpool. Maybe they just signed him to avoid having to play against him in the UEFA Cup... :))

deleted user [Visitor]

09/09/08 @ 12:42

While Liege as a whole played well against Liverpool, I would say he was one of the ones who made less of an impact over the two games. Like you say, maybe we signed him so he doesn't play against us :))!

aristides [Visitor]
http://englishfootie.wordpress.com/
17/09/08 @ 01:02

It’s no coincidence that all these tycoons seem to prefer english clubs instead of for example a spanish club. I personally believe that it is more possible for Hull City(!) to be the next club taken over by a rich russian rather than Valencia or something.It’s obvious that premiership clubs are much ahead of every other country’s football clubs in terms of marketing, fan base, popularity, loyalty, prospect, financial health and stadiums.

But is this what all english football fans in England and around the world would like to happen?Rich people spending crazy money for the sake of it? Having an owner, who has full control of a club, and spends his money according to his mood and personal interests?Is this the way to success?

RampageRampage team
22/09/08 @ 10:44

I know that I would feel less affection for my team if they were bought out.

There's something about the eternal struggle that makes a team easy to love - it's the falws that make them perfect.

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Recent Posts

  1. Ukraine game on the internet...
    by denzil85 on Friday, Oct. 09, 2009
  2. Title race still too predictable?
    by denzil85 on Monday, Oct. 05, 2009
  3. The Blades
    by shakeberry pro on Sunday, Sep. 20, 2009
  4. BCUK Fantasy Football Year Two
    by Rampage team on Tuesday, Aug. 11, 2009
  5. fantasy football
    by bmccluskey on Friday, Jul. 03, 2009
  6. Newcastle can still do it!
    by nufcplayer on Sunday, May. 03, 2009
  7. WATCH FOOTBALL HERE!
    by nufcplayer on Wednesday, Apr. 29, 2009
  8. Arsene......Wake up and smell the flowers.
    by wisty8golf on Tuesday, Feb. 24, 2009
  9. Football-The Good Old Days?
    by Northeasternviews on Thursday, Jan. 29, 2009
  10. Codename: Marmoset
    by ajnspencer pro on Thursday, Jan. 22, 2009

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.